Middle aged man consulting personal injury attorney.

Virginia personal injury lawyers don’t file lawsuits right out of the gate. Instead, they file a claim with the insurance company and enter into personal injury settlement negotiations to pursue compensation without the time and expense of going to court.

When you hire a personal injury lawyer at Marks & Harrison to represent you after an accident, we’ll go through a process to investigate and prepare a robust claim on your behalf. A thorough investigation by our legal team, which includes former law enforcement investigators and insurance claims adjusters, will greatly enhance our position when seeking a full and fair settlement amount on your behalf.

What Is a Personal Injury Settlement?

A personal injury settlement is an agreement between an injured person and the at-fault party’s insurance company. In exchange for compensation, the injured person agrees to resolve the claim without taking the case to trial. The money secured through a settlement may account for their medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other accident-related losses.

Once they’ve signed a settlement agreement, the injured person generally can’t seek additional compensation for the same injury later.

How Do Attorneys Determine What Your Case Is Worth?

Before settlement talks begin, your personal injury attorney at Marks & Harrison will work to understand the full extent of your losses and who may be responsible for paying them. They’ll compare the available insurance coverage to the expenses and losses you’ve suffered.

The following are the general steps involved in determining personal injury case value:

  • Thorough Investigation and Evidence Gathering – Your attorney will review accident scene documentation, police reports, official records, witness statements, photos, videos, and reports from accident reconstructionists or other expert witnesses.
  • Comprehensive Medical Documentation – Your lawyer may collect treatment records, medical bills, information about your prognosis, future care estimates, and life care plans in cases involving severe injuries.
  • Calculating Economic Damages – This step involves adding up your past and future medical costs, lost wages, reduced earning capacity, property damage, and out-of-pocket expenses.
  • Evaluating Non-Economic Damages – Your attorney will also consider less easily measurable harms like pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, disfigurement, and scarring.
  • Identifying All Liable Parties – More than one person, business, or insurer may share responsibility. Your personal injury lawyer will identify them all.
  • Researching Insurance Coverage and Policy Limits – The available coverage can affect your attorney’s settlement strategy.

What Is the Timeline for Personal Injury Settlement Negotiations?

The timeline for personal injury claim negotiations depends on the facts of the case, the severity of the injuries, and how the insurance company responds.

Attorneys typically wait until an injured person reaches maximum medical improvement or has a clear prognosis before sending a demand letter to the insurance company. After that, the insurer will review the claim and make an offer. At this point, negotiations can begin.

Some cases settle quickly, while others take months or longer to resolve. Every case is unique.

What Is a Settlement Demand Letter?

A settlement demand letter is a formal letter your attorney sends to the insurance company that explains your claim and outlines the compensation you seek. It describes how the accident happened, why the insured party is responsible, what injuries you sustained, the medical treatment you’ve received, and the financial and personal losses you’ve suffered due to the accident.

Attorneys often provide supporting evidence with the demand letter, such as medical records, bills, wage documentation, photographs, witness statements, and other records.

Should You Accept the Insurance Company’s Initial Offer?

Virginia law requires insurance companies to respond to claims in a timely fashion, usually within 15 calendar days. Their response may include a settlement offer, but you should be extremely wary of any initial offers, as they are rarely fair.

Before you accept an offer, your attorney will review it and compare it against the evidence. Your lawyer will then respond with a counteroffer that points to your medical records, lost income, future treatment, and the impact of the injury on your daily life to show why your claim warrants more compensation.

The best approach is to wait until you’ve reached maximum medical improvement before filing a claim so your lawyer can better account for your future care and lasting limitations.

What Factors Can Increase a Settlement’s Value?

Several case-specific factors can affect how much an insurance company may be willing to pay during settlement negotiations, including the following:

  • The Severity of Your Injuries – Serious injuries, permanent impairments, or long recovery periods may increase the value of your claim.
  • Evidence of Clear Liability – You may have a stronger case when the evidence clearly shows the other party caused the accident.
  • Significant Economic Losses – High medical bills, lost income, and reduced earning ability can support a larger demand.
  • Sympathetic Facts – Your age, the other party’s conduct, and the hardships you’ve suffered may work in your favor.
  • Strong Evidence – Having a high volume of photos, records, witnesses, and expert opinions to support your claim can strengthen your position in negotiations.
  • Whether You Have an Experienced Attorney on Your Side – A skilled Virginia personal injury lawyer at Marks & Harrison can push back against lowball offers and fight for what you deserve.

Do Most Personal Injury Cases Settle Before Trial?

Yes, the majority of personal injury cases settle before trial. Negotiating a settlement is generally much faster, less expensive, and less uncertain than relying on a judge or jury to decide the outcome.

However, whether a case settles depends on the evidence, the amount of compensation at issue, the available insurance coverage, and whether both sides can agree on a fair settlement. If the insurance company refuses to make a reasonable offer, filing a lawsuit may become necessary to keep pressure on the claim.

Contact a Virginia Personal Injury Lawyer

If you were injured in an accident someone else caused, engaging in the personal injury settlement negotiation process may provide your best path forward to recover the compensation you deserve. The team at Marks & Harrison can help. Since 1911, we’ve served Virginia clients harmed through other parties’ carelessness, and we’ve recovered over $1 billion for injured people.

Contact us 24/7 to arrange a free consultation with an experienced Virginia personal lawyer.

Charles W. Davis, Jr. is a Tappahannock native who earned his undergraduate degree from the University of Virginia and his law degree from the University of Richmond School of Law. He worked as a clerk at Marks & Harrison for two years before joining our law firm. For two years in a row, he was selected by his peers for the National Trial Lawyers’ Top 40 Under 40 list.